404 Challenge

Cup Stack Claw

Build a string-controlled claw that can grab and stack cups while introducing simple machines, remote control systems, and engineering iteration.

Grades 2-6 60-65 minutes Sticks, string, rubber bands Intermediate

Grade Level: 2-6
Time: 60-65 minutes
Group Size: 2-4 students per team

Materials Needed (per team):

  • 10-15 popsicle sticks
  • 2-3 yards of string or yarn
  • 4-6 rubber bands
  • Tape (masking or duct)
  • Scissors
  • Cardboard scraps (optional, for reinforcement)
  • 3 plastic or paper cups (solo cups work great)

The Challenge:

Design and build a mechanical claw that can pick up and stack 3 cups without touching them with your hands. The claw must be controlled by pulling strings - no direct touching allowed once the challenge starts!

Step-by-Step Instructions:

Setup (5 minutes):

  1. Set up a “building zone” for each team
  2. Place 3 cups on the table spread apart
  3. Explain the goal: stack all 3 cups into a tower using only the claw
  4. Demonstrate: show students a simple grabbing motion (though they’ll build their own design)

Planning Phase (10 minutes):

  1. Show students how a claw works:
    • It needs to OPEN to go around the cup
    • It needs to CLOSE to grip the cup
    • Strings control the opening and closing
  2. Basic claw concepts:
    • The Gripper: Two or more “fingers” that come together
    • The Handle: Something to hold while operating
    • The Controls: Strings that open/close the fingers

Building Phase (30-35 minutes):

Design Option 1: Simple Pincher Claw (Easier - Grades 2-3)

What you’re building: Two popsicle sticks that work like chopsticks

  1. Create the Fingers:
    • Take 2 popsicle sticks
    • These will be your grabbing “fingers”
  2. Add the Hinge:
    • Overlap the sticks at one end (about 1 inch overlap)
    • Wrap a rubber band around the overlap tightly
    • The sticks should be able to open and close like scissors
  3. Add Control Strings:
    • Tie a string to the end of each stick (the ends that open/close)
    • Make strings about 12-18 inches long
    • Pull strings apart = claw opens
    • Release strings = rubber band pulls claw closed
  4. Add a Handle (optional):
    • Tape a third popsicle stick perpendicular to the hinge as a handle

Design Option 2: Multi-Finger Claw (Harder - Grades 4-6)

What you’re building: A claw with 3-4 fingers that close around the cup

  1. Create the Base:
    • Use cardboard to cut a small circle (3-4 inches diameter)
    • This is the “palm” of your claw
  2. Attach the Fingers:
    • Use 3-4 popsicle sticks as fingers
    • Attach one end of each stick to the edge of the cardboard circle
    • Space them evenly around the circle
    • Use tape or small hinges made from paper clips
  3. Add the Closing Mechanism:
    • Thread ONE long string through small holes at the tip of each finger
    • OR tie individual strings to each finger
    • When you pull the string(s), all fingers should move inward toward center
  4. Create the Handle:
    • Attach a long stick or rolled cardboard tube to the center of the base
    • This lets you hold the claw above the cups
  5. Test the Grip:
    • Pull string = fingers close
    • Release = fingers open (you may need rubber bands to help them spring back)

Teacher Facilitation:

During Building (walk around and guide):

  • “Show me how your claw will close. What makes it close?”
  • “How will you control it from far away?”
  • “Try picking up a cup right now - does it work?”

Common Issues:

  • Claw won’t close tightly enough: Add rubber bands to pull fingers together
  • Can’t grip the cup: Make sure fingers curve inward, not straight
  • Cup slips out: Add texture to fingers (wrap with rubber band, add tape sticky-side-out)
  • Strings tangle: Use different colors or keep them separated

Testing Phase (15 minutes):

The Cup Stack Challenge - Official Rules:

  1. Place 3 cups spread out on the table
  2. Using ONLY the claw (no hands touching cups!), stack all 3 cups into a tower
  3. Tower must stand for 5 seconds
  4. Fastest time wins! (Or award points for successful stacking)

Scoring Options:

  • Completion: Did you successfully stack all 3 cups? (Yes = 10 points)
  • Speed: How long did it take? (Fastest = bonus points)
  • No Drops: Stack without dropping any cups (bonus points)
  • Creativity: Most creative claw design (teacher’s choice award)

Learning Objectives:

  • Simple machines: Levers and mechanical advantage
  • Cause and effect: Pulling string causes fingers to close
  • Engineering design: Iterating to improve grip and control
  • Hand-eye coordination: Controlling the claw precisely

Differentiation:

  • Easier:
    • Allow stacking just 2 cups
    • Make a simpler 2-stick pincher design
    • Let students touch cups to position them at the start
  • Harder:
    • Stack cups upside-down (narrower opening!)
    • Build a claw that can pick up other objects (small ball, eraser)
    • Add a height requirement: claw must lift cup 6 inches off table
  • Extension Challenge:
    • Create a claw that can open AND close by pulling different strings (one string opens, one closes)
    • Design a claw with a twisting motion (rotate the cup while holding it)

Safety Notes:

  • Scissors should be used carefully
  • If using hot glue, teacher supervision required
  • Make sure strings aren’t too long (tripping hazard)

Discussion Questions:

  • What made your claw work well? What didn’t work?
  • How did pulling the string make the fingers move?
  • Why was it hard to control the claw?
  • Where do you see claws or grippers in real life? (Arcade games, robot arms, construction equipment!)

Real-World Connections:

  • Robotic arms in factories use similar gripper mechanisms
  • Arcade claw machines use this same principle
  • Prosthetic hands work with similar control systems
  • Construction cranes have claws for lifting materials

Troubleshooting Guide:

Problem Solution
Claw won’t open Add rubber bands to pull fingers apart when string is released
Claw won’t close Pull string tighter; add more tension with rubber bands
Fingers too stiff Use thinner materials; make hinges looser
Can’t grip cup Add rubber bands around fingertips for friction; curve fingers inward
String keeps slipping Tie knots; add tape to secure string to sticks
Cup slips out Hold claw steadier; close fingers more tightly; add texture